Skip to product information
Build Your Own Box (6pcs.)
  • Build Your Own Box (6pcs.)
  • Build Your Own Box (6pcs.)
Build Your Own Box (6pcs.)

Build Your Own Box (6pcs.)

$60.88

Mix and match from our award-winning goat and cow cheeses to design a box that’s uniquely yours. Whether you crave creamy chèvre, bold blue, or nutty aged cheddar, you’re in control of every flavor on your cheeseboard.

Select your cheeses:

Selected 0 of 6

$60.88 USD
$54.79 USD

Auto-renews, skip or cancel anytime.

To add to cart, go to the product page and select a purchase option

Our cheeses:

Shire - Pasteurized Cow Milk Hard Aged Cheese
2023 American Cheese Society 1st Place Award Winner

Shire is a natural-rind, hard-aged cow's milk cheese. During the cheese-making process, the curds are washed with Shire Ale, an award-winning Scotch-style ale produced by Hopshire Brewery located in Dryden, NY.

Shelf life: 6 months

Weight: 4 oz

Aged time: at least 30 days

Sheldrake Moon - Pasteurized Cow Milk Brie-Style Cheese

Sheldrake Moon, named for the reflection of the moon on the waters of Cayuga Lake at Sheldrake Point, is a bloomy-rind, a brie-style cheese, made from whole cow's milk. As the cheese ages, the paste develops a lovely cream line that gives the cheese a lusciously rich texture. Lively Run Sheldrake Moon pairs excellently with dry Riesling and Champagne-style dry ciders, as well as stone fruit.

Shelf life: 2 months

Weight: 8 oz wheel

Aged time: 14 days
Blue Yonder - Pasteurized Cow Milk Blue Cheese
2023 American Cheese Society 1st Place Award Winner

Blue Yonder is a natural rind cow milk blue cheese. Aged for at least sixty days, it develops a pungent, slightly spicy flavor contrasted by a rich, fudge-like texture from the high butterfat content. This is a great melting blue cheese, perfect for use in burgers or blue cheese pasta sauce. Rich and intense, Blue Yonder is a blue cheese lover’s delight, pairing well with wines, honey, and red meats.

Shelf life: 6 months

Weight: 4 oz

Aged time: 60 days
Lake Effect Cheddar - Pasteurized New York-Style Cow Milk Cheddar
2023 American Cheese Society 1st Place Award Winner

Aged for at least six months, Lake Effect Cheddar has a creamy texture that showcases the milk it is made from. This Cheddar's sharpness is offset by a subtle underlying nutty sweetness. Its bold flavor makes it a great featured ingredient for dishes like cheddar biscuits or cheddar-broccoli soup.

Shelf life: 6 months

Weight: 8 oz

Aged time:

Finger Lakes Gold - Pasteurized Goat Milk Hard Aged Cheese
2023 & 2022 American Cheese Society Award Winner

Aged for at least three months, Finger Lakes Gold cheese offers a mellow, nutty flavor with a firm texture and golden-yellow rind. Grassy notes and a burnt sugar finish characterize its taste, reflecting the Finger Lakes terroir. It's a unique addition to any cheese board, complementing cured meats, jams, or fruit. It also pairs well with dry Rieslings, crisp lagers, light ales, and tart jams.

Shelf life: 6 months

Weight: 4 oz

Aged time: at least 90 days
Finger Lakes Gold Reserve - Pasteurized Goat Milk Hard Aged Cheese
2023, 2022 & 2019 American Cheese Society Award Winner

Finger Lakes Gold Reserve is a hard-aged goat cheese, aged for at least 300 days from Lively Run's original recipe. As it matures, its flavors deepen, revealing rich burnt sugar notes and a pronounced bone broth/umami essence. Honored as the 2019 ACS Competition class winner and ranked among the top 15 Best In Show cheeses, it pairs excellently with a Perfect Manhattan, cured meats, or aged balsamic vinegar.

Shelf life: 6 months

Weight: 4 oz

Aged time: 1 year
Chevre - Fresh Pasteurized Goat Milk Cheese

Chèvre is delicate, with a creamy texture balanced by a slight lactic tang and grassy, pastoral notes. It is a highly versatile cooking cheese, equally suitable for savory dishes such as cheese dips or salads, and sweet recipes like cheesecake or panna cotta.

Shelf life: 6 months

Weight: 8 oz

Aged time:

Cayuga Blue - Pasteurized Goat Milk Blue Cheese
2022, 2018 & 2017 American Cheese Society Award Winner

Cayuga Blue is a rare, natural-rind goat milk blue cheese with marbled blue mold as deep in color as the lake it was named after. It offers rich earthy and mushroom flavors with a hint of nutty sweetness. It pairs perfectly with off-dry Riesling, raspberry jam, and chocolate. Ideal for dishes featuring beef or mushrooms, its crumbly texture also makes it perfect for salads.

Shelf life: 4 months

Weight: 4 oz

Aged time: 45 days
Feta - Greek Style Salt Brind Pasteurized Goat Milk Cheese
2024 American Cheese Society 3rd Place Award Winner

Traditional Greek-style Feta is aged for a minimum of two weeks in salt brine, resulting in a crumbly texture with a salty kick. In addition to its traditional use in salads, Feta pairs beautifully with pork.

Shelf life: 6 months

Weight: 4 oz

Aged time:

You may also like